|
Location(s):
Alternative Middle Years (AMY) at James Martin
Cassidy, Lewis C. Academics Plus School
Holme, Thomas School
Description: The structure proposed in this action item is comprised of three school building projects to be developed with the help of PAID. The three projects recommended for an intergovernmental cooperation agreement with PAID are included in the approved FY22 capital budget or the Five Year Capital Improvement Program. The partnership with PAID is expected to provide additional oversight and assistance to the District, with the anticipated outcome of new school building constructed at reasonable cost, with greater efficiencies, and on time completion.
The partnership with PAID aligns with the requirements around the funding stream for these projects. The School District was awarded federal ESSER grant funds, of $145,000,000, to be spent on projects that would enhance the health and safety of students. By regulation or law, all ESSER funds must be obligated by September 30, 2024. For the District to use the ESSER funds for construction projects on District property, the District must be the owner of or have at least 50 years’ possession of the property(ies) where the funds would be spent. Given the aggressive grant timeframe, carrying out the three projects using a traditional Design-Bid-Build model is not feasible. And because the District must own or have at least 50 years’ possession of the buildings to be eligible to use for the funding, a turn-key structure, whereby the District would convey property to a developer, is not technically viable. On the other hand, a structure involving PAID (managed by PIDC), would enable the District to lease properties to PAID, with PAID in turn subleasing the properties to a Developer or “CM at Risk” (collectively “developers”) for the design and construction of the school projects on a timeline that complies with the grant’s terms, while maintaining the District as the property owner. The Pennsylvania Department of Education, which administers the federal ESSER grant funding, has indicated they will approve use of the ESSER funds under this structure for the three enumerated projects.
Each of the new school buildings will be constructed on the same parcel on which it currently exists. Students attending each of the schools will be relocated before demolition of existing structures begins and after construction is completed. All of these projects should be completed, with students returned, by School Year 2024-2025. The AMY at James Martin and Thomas Holme projects will be carried out by a developer. The developer will provide design services, inclusive of planning, design and construction, while the Cassidy school project will be constructed by a CM at Risk given the stage of the project, as further described below.
The Projects
Alternative Middle Years at James Martin, located at 3350 Richmond Street, Philadelphia, PA 19134, serves 550 6th-8th grade students. The AMY at James Martin school project was approved for capital improvement and included in the adopted Capital Improvement Plan for FY21. This project is currently in the planning stage. Because the program of requirement is under development, using a developer is the appropriate structure. The scope of work for this project includes educational planning, design, building construction, site work including stormwater management systems, casework, furnishing, fixtures, equipment, communications, and security. The developer will be required to comply with the District’s Educational Specifications, Design Guidelines, Technical Specifications, and program of requirement that are in place. This will set the standard of quality, size, and layout with which the developer must comply. The new building is being designed to serve approximately 550 6th-8th grade students in a, most likely, three-story, approximately 77,900 square foot space. The new school design will include 15 classrooms, three small group instruction rooms, an instructional media center, spaces for art and music, three science labs, a discovery commons, a gymnatorium, a cafeteria, and a full service kitchen. The school leadership, students, and parents will be engaged throughout the design and construction processes to provide input on public spaces on a quarterly basis.
Lewis C. Cassidy Academics Plus School, located at 6523 Lansdowne Avenue, Philadelphia, PA 19151, serves 600 children in Pre-K through 8th grade. The Cassidy school project was approved for capital improvement and included in the adopted Capital Improvement Plan for FY19, and the Office of Capital Programs retained Ewing Cole, Inc. to provide professional architectural services pursuant to Board authorization given on June 25, 2020. The project is currently in the design phase under the direction of JMT, the District’s Project Management firm, in conjunction with the Office of Capital Programs (OCP). The design is approximately ninety percent complete, including the program of requirement, standard of quality, defined systems and specifications. Therefore, a CM at Risk structure is appropriate and planned as part of the transactions with PAID. The scope of work for this project includes building construction, site work including stormwater management systems, casework, furnishing, fixtures, equipment, communications, and security. The newly constructed building will have a projected enrollment of 600 students. As being planned, the building will be three stories, with approximately 83,000 square feet. The new school design will include 27 classrooms, four small group instruction rooms, an instructional media center, spaces for art, music and science, a maker space, a gymnatorium, a cafeteria, and a full service kitchen. The school leadership, students, and parents have been engaged throughout the design process and provided input on murals, playground, community spaces and the general appearance of the school. These community meetings have been occurring on a quarterly basis during design and are expected to continue throughout the construction phase.
Thomas Holme School, located at 9125 Academy Road, Philadelphia, PA 19114, serves 950 Pre-K through 8th grade students. The Holme school project was approved for capital improvement and included in the adopted Capital Improvement Plan for FY20. This project is currently in the planning stage. Because the program of requirement is under development, using a developer is the appropriate structure. The scope of work for this project includes educational planning, design, building construction, site work including stormwater management systems, casework, furnishing, fixtures, equipment, communications, and security. The developer will be required to comply with the District’s Educational Specifications, Design Guidelines, Technical Specifications, and program of requirement that are in place. This will set the standard of quality, size, and layout with which the developer must comply. The new building will most likely be three-stories, serving approximately 950 Pre-K through 8th grade students, in an approximately 113,850 square foot space. The new school design will include 35 classrooms, three small group instruction rooms, an instructional media center, spaces for art, music, and science, a dance studio, a discovery commons, a gymnatorium, a cafeteria, and a full service kitchen. The school leadership, students, and parents will be engaged throughout the design and construction processes to provide input on public spaces on a quarterly basis.
School District Oversight
OCP has developed the Design Guidelines, Educational Specifications, and Technical Specifications to ensure high quality construction that is responsive to the academic needs of our students. All three projects will be required to meet the School District's Program of Requirements, Design Guidelines and Technical Specifications, and Educational and Technical Specifications. The specifications include risk mitigation requirements to protect the District, such as payment and performance bond requirements, insurance requirements, and contingencies requirements. The School District, with PAID’s assistance, will participate in vendor selection for design and construction through a Request for Proposal (RFP) process. PAID will issue the RFP, which will incorporate and be consistent with School contracting goals and provisions, including MWBE goals. The District will have responsibility with respect to the RFP, reviewing proposals, contract negotiations and preparation (in collaboration with PAID, who will award the contracts), construction design approval/management, construction management and inspection, project controls/cost estimates, reviewing and approving invoices and payment, training, regular monitoring that the project is adhering to established standards, schedules and budgets, project close-out, and lease termination. (Additional information below.)
Services to be Rendered by PAID
As referenced above, the District will be paying a not-to-exceed capped fee to PAID. PAID will be collaborating with the District on the projects and providing a range of specific services. These include (i) executing and delivering leases with the School District and subleases with the developers; (ii) working with the District to create an RFP for developers of the respective construction projects that is mutually agreeable to the School District and PAID; issuing the RFP on behalf of the School District; (iii) participating as a member of the developer selection committee established by the School District and appointing each developer at the School District’s direction; (iv) participating with the School District in the negotiation of agreements and contracts with developers and the subleases with the developers (“Developer Agreements”), and executing and delivering all Developer Agreements; and (v) managing the invoice process with developers. Developers will be required to submit invoices and necessary supporting documentation to PAID.PAID will review the invoices to ensure the invoices and accompanying back-up information are complete, and will submit a copy of the invoice with a requisition form to the School District.Upon receipt from the School District of written authorization and funds to pay the invoice, PAID will pay the developers.
Transaction Structure Benefits
PAID has significant experience with large scale construction programs for the City of Philadelphia and City-related authorities, and PDE has approved use of the federal funds for these projects. This structure moreover will result in several efficiencies and cost savings and, fits with the time constraints relating to the expenditure of the federal grant funds being used to fund construction of the projects (which must be spent by September 2024).
Furthermore, while no construction project is risk free regardless of how it is structured, certain assurances protecting the District will be embedded in the contract documents, and the District will be assuming no greater risk than is inherent in any of our construction contracts. The contracts PAID will enter into with the developers will require the developers to deliver the project for the cost of the work, but for no greater than a guaranteed maximum price. In this way, the risk of cost overruns shifts away from the District. The risk of overruns if the guaranteed maximum price is exceeded will contractually be borne by the developers. In addition, it is expected that the contracts will include liquidated damages and indemnification provisions. The School District will also mitigate risks in connection with these construction projects by reviewing the financials of the selected developers, and requiring warranties for the work performed and payment and performance bonds that are legally required on all District construction projects.
The District will maintain input and oversight for the project. The District’s in-house team of architects, engineers, and construction professionals will allow the District to assign a complete project team for each of the three projects under development, inclusive of a Design Project Manager, a Construction Project Manager, and inspectors. The developers will be required to complete the projects within the established budget and schedule under OCP’s oversight and management. Progress will be monitored on a weekly basis against a baseline schedule that will be established by the developers within the first several weeks of their contract(s), all within the 30-month time frame allotted for the projects. OCP will be responsible for ensuring the project schedule is updated with the latest information by developers so that it is never more than three business days out of date. For variances on critical milestones greater than five business days, the developers will be issued a written request to provide a recovery schedule within three business days.
Communication management will rest with the District, with cooperation of the developers. Communication threads will follow the common path of project leadership from inspector and Construction Project Manager to Construction Manager, to OCP leadership, School Principal and Assistant Superintendent, to the Chief Operating Officer, and from there to the District’s Superintendent. The District will also be heavily involved with community and stakeholder communications. Quarterly design meetings will be scheduled to engage the community in the planning and design process and to seek input and feedback. The District will also coordinate pre-construction meetings and quarterly construction meetings to update the community on the progress of the projects, similar to the community engagement the District has conducted for various projects and stages, such as the T.M. Pierce, Solis-Cohen, and Northeast Community Propel Academy projects. The District will consult with school leaders at all stages of the projects.
The District will provide updates to the Board at regular intervals and/or project milestones, as agreed to between the Board President and the District.
This action item supports Board Guardrail 1: Welcoming and Supportive Schools- Every school will be a safe, welcoming, and healthy place where our students, staff, and community want to be and learn each day.
Funding source(s):
FY21-22 Capital Budget - FY22-25 Federal ESSER III- ARPA
|